Toastee Bagels

Alise Dennison 5 months ago

As a bagel connoisseur I can honestly say I was very impressed with this bagel shop! There were so many types of bagel flavors and homemade cream cheeses, and that’s before you even get to the sandwich options! I tried the seasonal lemon poppy bagel with the blueberry cream cheese. It was absolutely wonderful! The place was incredibly clean, and the employees were awesome. I only wish I lived closer!

Chuck Y 6 months ago

Ordered 2 breakfast bagels with egg, sausage and cheese. Overall the sandwich was good but expected a fresher bagel. The bagel didn't have the freshness you would expect from a bagel shop. Great selection of brewed coffees including regular, decaf and flavored varieties. Service was excellent and the atmosphere is perfect for a bagel/Sandwich Shop. My recommendation is you might want to ask first which bagels are the freshest and base your selection from there.

Jack Montelbano 7 months ago

I almost fell to my knees in a Walmart when my buddy texted me about this place. As a NJ Native, I would only have the opportunity to get a jersey bagel when I visited home, but not anymore! As the self appointed Jersey Bagel gatekeeper, I was really excited to try this place out so I hopped in my car at 645am and drove 30 mins to grab some breakfast sandwiches. The inside of this place feels like home to me, coffee pots on the counter, 5 people behind the counter all looking busy, and most importantly BASKETS OF BAGELS BEHIND THE TELLER. This was an absolute dream come true and yes...the FOOD IS AMAZING. We got a plain bagel with lox and cream cheese, and a Taylor ham egg and cheese on an egg bagel. The bagels were great, nice and fluffy on the inside, with a slightly crispy shell that gives jersey bagels that awesome texture. Every kid with a license needs to be here on Saturday and Sunday mornings in their pajamas - it's the jersey way. Side note: when I ordered my Taylor ham egg and cheese they didn't blink. Usually I get asked "what's that?". Couldn't believe it. Also the kitchen looks brand new and I'm assuming it is. The entire place looked squeaky clean!

Jordan J 7 months ago

Order a total of (2) bagels: hot ham and cheese bagel & a bacon egg & cheese bagel with hashbrown, Salt pepper ketchup. To start I had to repeat my order about 3-4 times to the cashier. Then waited a few minutes for my order which is completely normal. My order came, brought it home and opened my bagels up. This is the smallest amount of Ham I’ve ever seen on a bagel in my life and my bacon egg and cheese has NO salt, pepper, or ketchup on it as requested and maybe has 1-2 pieces of bacon on it picture was the other half of my bagel with a tiny piece of bacon. For $17 plus tip I’d expect a little more love on my breakfast bagels…

Julio Santos 8 months ago

Thanks for coming to my states we need something like your company I am tired in going someplace. Dirty not clean at all and the food miss some thing or cold. And the employees so sad and rude when ask for something but Here I am very appreciated very good atmosphere. And very clean delicious food and bagels 🥯 amazing thanks again. I am back soon 🔜 lol 😂 l